Fresh Seafood Markets Near Pine Knoll Shores, NC

By Hollis Ward 6 min read

One of the best parts of renting a house in Pine Knoll Shores is cooking fresh seafood in your own kitchen. The Crystal Coast is a working fishing coast - commercial boats dock in Morehead City and Beaufort daily - and the seafood markets near Bogue Banks sell fish that was swimming hours ago. You do not need to eat at a restaurant every night to eat well on this part of the North Carolina coast.

Here is where to buy the good stuff near Pine Knoll Shores.

On the Island: Willis Seafood Market

Willis Seafood Market at 130 Headen Lane in Salter Path is the closest seafood market to Pine Knoll Shores and the only one on Bogue Banks proper. It is about a five-minute drive west on Salter Path Road.

Willis has been in business since 1934. They catch their own shrimp, crabs, oysters, and scallops - nothing is farm-raised, nothing is imported. What is in the case depends on what came off the boats that day and what is in season. During summer, expect fresh shrimp, live blue crabs, oysters, clams, scallops, and whatever finfish the fleet brought in.

The Vesta Crabcake is their signature prepared item - made in-house and worth buying even if you came in for raw shrimp. They also make key lime pie. Hours are generally daily from 9 AM to about 7:30 PM, though you should call (252) 247-2752 to confirm, especially early and late in the season.

If you are cooking seafood at your rental, Willis is your first stop. Buy the shrimp, grab a lemon and some Old Bay at the grocery store, and you have dinner sorted in 20 minutes.

Across the Bridge: Morehead City Markets

Morehead City is about 15 minutes from Pine Knoll Shores across the Atlantic Beach bridge, and it has several seafood markets that are worth the drive.

Captain Jim’s Seafood Market

Captain Jim’s at 4665 Arendell Street in Morehead City is a fisherman’s market that has been operating for over 20 years. The inventory rotates with the seasons. In summer, expect grouper, king mackerel, mahi-mahi, snapper, striped bass, yellowfin tuna, and shrimp. In winter, the focus shifts to hard-shell blue crabs, bluefish, clams, oysters, and sea trout.

Captain Jim’s has a steam room where they will steam your seafood for you. Buy a pound of shrimp and they will have it ready to eat by the time you finish browsing. Open Wednesday through Saturday 9 AM to 6 PM and Sunday 10 AM to 4 PM. Closed Monday and Tuesday. Check their website at captjimsseafoodmarket.com for the current catch.

Blue Ocean Market

Blue Ocean Market has locations at 108 Atlantic Beach Causeway and 2400 Bridges Street in Morehead City. They focus on sustainably caught seafood from North Carolina waters - fresh fish, live lobster, sushi-grade fish, whole fish, and fresh oysters. Chef-prepared meals are also available if you want something ready to heat and eat.

The Atlantic Beach Causeway location is seasonal, so call ahead to confirm it is open. The Morehead City location operates year-round. Hours are generally Monday through Saturday 9 AM to 6 PM and Sunday 10 AM to 5 PM. Phone: (252) 499-4087.

Atlantic Beach Seafood and Fresh Market

Atlantic Beach Seafood and Fresh Market at 415 Atlantic Beach Causeway is on the causeway between the island and the mainland. Fresh shrimp, crab, clams, seasonal fish, and Carteret oysters. They also carry olive oil, wine, beer, spices, loose tea, local jams, and candles - so you can pick up dinner and a few gifts in one stop.

Their steam pots are popular: a combination of shrimp, clams, sausage, and corn with your choice of seasoning, ready to eat. They also make homemade pies.

Open Thursday through Saturday 10 AM to 6 PM and Sunday 10 AM to 5 PM. Closed Monday through Wednesday. Phone: (252) 247-2430. The limited schedule means you need to plan ahead - do not count on a Wednesday run.

Further Afield: Beaufort

Fishtowne Seafood

Fishtowne Seafood at 100 Wellons Drive in Beaufort buys directly from local fishermen and operates both a retail market and a wholesale processing facility. Their selection includes flounder, yellowfin tuna, mahi-mahi, grouper, snapper, oysters, clams, scallops, shrimp, crabs, and sea mullet.

Beaufort is about a 20-minute drive from Pine Knoll Shores. If you are planning a day trip to Beaufort, stopping at Fishtowne on the way back to pick up dinner is a solid move. Open generally 9 AM to 6 PM - call (252) 728-6644 to confirm days and hours.

What Is in Season on the Crystal Coast

The seafood you find at these markets changes with the seasons. Here is a rough guide for what to look for:

  • Summer (June through August): Shrimp, mahi-mahi, yellowfin tuna, king mackerel, grouper, soft-shell crabs, flounder. This is peak season for variety and availability.
  • Fall (September through November): Shrimp, spot, mullet, oysters (beginning of oyster season), hard-shell blue crabs, flounder.
  • Winter (December through February): Oysters, clams, blue crabs, bluefish, sea trout.
  • Spring (March through May): Shrimp season opens, flounder returns, soft-shell crabs start showing up.

The seasonal seafood calendar goes deeper on what to expect each month and how to prepare it.

Tips for Buying Fresh Seafood Near Pine Knoll Shores

  • Ask what came in today. The staff at these markets know what is freshest. Whatever they are most excited about is what you should buy.
  • Smell the fish. Fresh seafood smells like the ocean, not like fish. If it smells strong or off, skip it.
  • Buy shrimp head-on if you can. Head-on shrimp is fresher and more flavorful. You peel it yourself, which takes five minutes, and the difference is worth it.
  • Bring a cooler. Keep one in the car during your Pine Knoll Shores vacation. When you make a seafood market run, the cooler keeps everything cold on the drive back to the rental.
  • Check hours twice. Several of these markets operate on limited schedules. Atlantic Beach Seafood is only open Thursday through Sunday. Captain Jim’s is closed Monday and Tuesday. Plan your shopping around their hours, not the other way around.
  • Freeze what you will not cook tonight. If you buy more than you need for one meal, portion and freeze the rest in zip-lock bags. Most rental kitchens have a freezer that handles this just fine.

The Crystal Coast is one of the few places where you can buy seafood directly from the people who caught it, cook it at your rental in Pine Knoll Shores, and eat better than most restaurants serve - all for less money. Stock the cooler, fire up the stove, and eat like a local on Bogue Banks.